|
Bank Secrecy Is Over! |
You buy that one, and I've got a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you.
Today, the hot tax story is that almost 15,000 American crooks – I mean taxpayers – have disclosed their offshore accounts to the IRS and will now pay back billions of tax dollars. IRS Commissioner Doug Shulman was absolutely ecstatic in reporting the good news.
This comes as the U.S. and Swiss governments announced an agreement that outlines how Swiss bank UBS will hand over data on U.S. citizens hiding money in foreign bank accounts. To listen to some of the news reports, you would think that the IRS just won the Super Bowl.
Don’t believe it. In reality, Shulman’s declaration of victory is the biggest overstatement since “Mission Accomplished!”
I do feel sorry for the Commissioner, though. He probably got as much Swiss bank information as the State Department would let him get – which is pretty much bupkis. And I have no doubt that he will pursue citizens who cheat on their taxes as vigorously as he can.
But betting that this agreement between the U.S. and the Swiss ends bank secrecy as we know it is a sucker’s bet.
I listen to Senator Carl Levin because he knows the score. In a statement today he said that the agreement now getting so much hype “shows the Swiss Government trying to preserve as much bank secrecy as it can for the future, while pushing to conceal the names of tens of thousands of suspected U.S. tax cheats. It is disappointing that the U.S. government went along.”
Disappointing indeed.
UBS has released the criteria for reporting to the IRS accounts. These would
for the most part have balances greater than approximately $900,000.
However, the IRS requires that accounts greater that $10,000 be reported.
This creates a sort of dichotomy:
Many individuals who have accounts between $10,000 – $900,000 have voluntarily
disclosed. But how fair is it for the IRS to monetarily punish these
individuals who wished to obey the law by disclosing, and on the other hand
have the U.S government look the other way for those who did not disclose?
Since the UBS will now not report these accounts of less that $900,000, it is
unlikely that these will now be discovered by the IRS and will therefore not
face any penalties at all.
This would send out a strange message indeed to the past and future individuals
who did or would wish to become complient.
Posted by Fred Hutchinson on Dec. 20, 2009 at 11:49 AM
Permalink | Comment | Trackback | Share | Other Posts by Christopher Bergin
All views expressed on these blogs are those of their individual authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Tax Analysts. Further, Tax Analysts makes no representation concerning the views expressed and does not guarantee the source, originality, accuracy, completeness or reliability of any statement, fact, information, data, finding, interpretation, or opinion presented. Tax Analysts particularly makes no representation concerning anything found on external links connected to this site.

CNBC
New York Times
The Hill
Philly.com

White House: Obama Urges Support for Small Business